A pair of competitive athletes are moving back east with their kids from Montana to Summerville, South Carolina. She wants a place that's turnkey with a pool, but he's intent on a scoring a deal by negotiating on a fixer.

A newlywed couple looks to buy their first home in Philadelphia. One wants a big suburban house with a yard, but the other prefers to keep their current city lifestyle in a townhouse.

Transplants in Washington, DC, look to put down roots in their new city. One prefers a charming row home to fix up with his family's help, but the other doesn't want any projects and thinks a modern condo is a better choice.

A couple is ready to buy their first home in Raleigh, North Carolina. She's fine with a fixer and hoping for a place with lots of character, but he's more focused on the home's functionality and prefers a new build.