as Elliott

as Peter Jackson

as Johnny Sirocco

as Avery Chasten

as Robert

as Samuel Ludlow

as Date 4 - Barry

as Rawlins

as Tim Wheddon

as Self

as Self

as Cody

as Jack

as Man of God

as Young Norman Bates

as Josh Petri

as Danceny

as Greg Hayes

as Frank

as Simon Cotton

as Davey Osborne

as Alex

as Self

as William

as Eric Rykell

as Seth

as Andrew

as Tom Brackett

as Aaron

as Hank Williams / "Mr. Wells" / Luke

as Dylan McCarthy

as Harry

as John St. Helens

as Nick Parker

as Jeff

as Dan Crandall

as Raymond Toker

as Philip Whalen

as Bern Venters

as Billy Isaacs

as Wesley Tate

as Buck

as Kevin

as Ron

as (archive footage)

as Edgar Macbeth

as Paul Weston

as Tim Grinnell

as Jamie

as Father Tom

as Ray Buckey

as Frank Davis

as Tom

as Self

as Vinson Filyaw

as John Thompson

as Thompson

as Cary Sloan

as Self

as Self

as Luke

as The Bartender

as Self - Interviewee

as Nick

as Self

as Mr. Kavinsky

as Self

as Nathaniel Matheson

as Pastor Mike

as Self

as Matt Erhorn

as Elliott

as Executive Producer